Eviction Delays: How Bad Tenants Buy More Time

by Chris on June 27, 2011

They don’t pay the rent. They don’t take care of the rental property. Still, they feel like their landlord owes them a place to live. Meet the professional tenant. Savvy to the legal system, these tenants have learned how to game their way into free rent, over and over again. How do they do it? Take a look at the strategies:

Bargain for More Time
Tenants will approach the landlord and ask for a longer period to pay. Or, they may try making a partial payment.

There’s usually a sad story, designed to make the landlord feel guilty.

To avoid falling for the strategy, just keep in mind that your rental property is a business, and there are other options for a tenant who is truly indigent. Negotiating for a longer period of time will not solve the problem, only perpetuate it.

File your notice to terminate the tenancy and get on the docket for an eviction.

That said, in some cases it may make sense to negotiate the tenant’s exit–cash for keys, if they need their deposit money and you need them out without paying for an eviction or any damage to the property.

Respond to the Eviction Complaint
Any response to the landlord’s eviction proceedings likely will generate a short grace period–10 days or much longer, under the rules for eviction. A typical response is to deny the landlord’s claims and ask for a hearing, or complain about conditions on the property–typically for the first time, in order to claim an offset against unpaid rent or damages.

If the tenant has talked with a lawyer–free tenant legal help is available everywhere, they may raise technical challenges regarding the service of the notice, or the contents on the notice, possibly leading to a dismissal and refiling, and an even longer grace period.

Landlords who have not followed local eviction rules to the letter, or who have allowed late payment behavior in the past are the most vulnerable to these challenges. If the tenant gets their way, the case will be set for a hearing, causing additional delays–from about three weeks to several months.

Beg the Judge
Tenants who don’t know how to use the legal system can still delay simply by writing a letter to the judge spelling out all of their concerns, or showing up to ask the court for a delay in execution of the order for possession. A sympathetic judge may encourage the landlord to “work something out.”

Continue the Hearing
Showing up with an excuse at the hearing is another effective delay tactic. For instance, the tenant may claim they need more time to hire an attorney, or have a medical issue. It’s up to the individual judge whether to get tough or to reschedule the case a few days or weeks down the road.

Show up for the hearing prepared to go forward, and explain the inequity of any further delay.  You also may be able to request that the tenant supply the court with  proof of the reason for the continuance.

File Bankruptcy
A desperate tenant may file bankruptcy to delay the eviction. While the case will proceed eventually, it may become necessary to work through the eviction process with the permission of the bankruptcy trustee or judge. Even then, any claim for damages may be history. Tenants may have the option of dismissing the bankruptcy filing a few days later, after it served its intended purpose.

Trash and Leave
If the tenant is not responding to the eviction in court, they may be biding their time, living rent-free, and waiting for the last possible minute to vacate. There is a risk the tenant may be taking out their frustrations on the property. It’s not uncommon for the tenant to leave behind heavy items, trash or pets, while taking more valuable treasures–appliances, copper and furnishings, along with them.

After all, what do they have lose?

Careful tenant screening is the best eviction-avoidance strategy a landlord has. Running a tenant credit check can show if this tenant is a pro. Knowing if there is a prior eviction history is a significant indicator of a repeat performance. Also, check for a criminal background, especially crimes that involve fraud, bad checks, and other devious methods.

This post is provided by Tenant Verification Service, Inc., helping landlords reduce the risks of renting with fraud prevention tools that include Tenant Screening, Tenant Background Checks, (U.S. and Canada), as well as Criminal Background Checks, and Eviction Reports (U.S. only).

Click Here to Receive Landlord Credit Reports.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this post in not intended to be construed as legal advice, nor should it be considered a substitute for obtaining individual legal counsel or consulting your local, state, federal or provincial tenancy laws.

{ 8 comments… read them below or add one }

Jay May 17, 2017 at 3:09 pm

My upstairs neighbors are very noisy and does some awful things to disturb my peace. They drop and drop heavy objects on the floor. One of the male tenants even threatened me, and punched the owner. Long story short, they are being evicted. They were given three months, but had not yet moved thought time has since lapsed. According to the owner the marshal gave them and additional four weeks.
These tenants are home all day, every day. I know they have not been actively looking for and apartment. I think they might have pulled a fast one on all parties involve.
Is there anything I can do to get them out, since I am the one most affected by this? I live in Brooklyn NY.
Thank you

Rebecca January 14, 2018 at 11:28 am

I live in sec 8 Housing, my Tennant advisor claimed he post a 14day notice on my door a month ago for breach of contract for not paying the rent. I had a meeting stating that I was having surgery in a week, but I payed last month’s rent I asked him if I can pay the remaining rent in a few weeks with a loan from my income tax return. He did not say anything . That day I was served with papers to appear in court in a few weeks. Is this legal? I’ll be incapacitated for a few weeks I can’t be moving and need to heal from open surgery of cancer. From new mexico

Tony Russo April 28, 2018 at 5:09 pm

What if a Tenant knowingly lies on the form, Answer To A Residential Eviction, and it can easily be proven they lied to delay the eviction to get more free rent, will the court take any action against their false statements?

Tatiana McGlorthan July 15, 2018 at 11:46 am

I am not a bad tenant. However, I have paid my rent late by about a week a few times in the past because I always get paid on the 5th or the 12th. Anyway I’m in a bind now because I started a new job for the summer and they did not pay me on time. I already talked with the leasing company and requested an extension for the 13th however when payday came supposedly there was a clearance issue with admin and my boss is now not picking up the phone. Can I request another extension? Even without knowing the next time I will be paid? I anticipate receiving a check prior to 7/31 which is the next payday. But am really not sure please help.

sandra February 25, 2019 at 11:21 am

I am a landlord, i have a very bad tenant, I serve him eviction notice it has been six months going on to seven months he does not want to leave, they are filing court days for more time to stay they do not pay rent, they live rent free, in the meanwhile i have to pay my mortgage. i am so desperate

donna j bergevin June 7, 2019 at 5:15 am

I have a landlord who is 87 years old. I have paid my rent every month. I complained about the rats that come in the house and chew up all kinds of things. My apartment is infested with rats and aunts.. I called the county Vector control. A inspor cam

ut and saw that the rats are in all apartments. I didn’t sign up for this egregious.
things . I told the landlord about my range. The .ooven doesn’t work and the burners are a mess.He told me to use a convection oven. I can’t believe that he will not replace the range. The plumbing is not working and we have a hard time I am not living alone. My son and my 7 year old grandson live here with me. My grandson is terrifoff the rats…rats come in and they are not afraid of you. .I have Congestive Heart Failure. This condition was just found . I am seventy five years old. I just spent 10 days in the hospital.

The landlord seems to forget all of the time. The other tenets all have rats. They’re.saying that the landlord. Is.senile because he is acting he doesn’t remember or he just doesnt care. Dont get me wrong because I am packing and looking for another place to be. He is definitely a slumlord
There are other things that are so numerous for it would take all day I just want to know what to do

Terry September 16, 2020 at 5:07 pm

Tenants have lived in my home now for 8 months. Finally today was court,judge canceled and sent it to district court. All on account of the tenant making a land contract, and forging my name. Now attorney says 6000 dollars and 6 months to a year. Am besides my self. Meanwhile I’m losing everything I have worked for. Corona related?

Ana Herazo December 4, 2020 at 9:56 am

I have tried to get legal advice from government institutions, spoken to lawyers with no avail
Tenat owes over $7000 , yet I have been told that there is nothing that can be done. Landlords have been forced to provide shelter and no one out here in .nj. meanwhile, I have to keep on paying mortgage, etc.
All responsibilities have been put
On landlords. I don’t want to compromise my property to ask for forbearance. This I think is not the right approach with this
Pandemic mess. Thank u.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: