Top 5 Mistakes Landlords Make with Tenancy Agreements

by | Oct 8, 2018 | Rental Forms

Unfortunately, there is no one universally applicable tenancy agreement form that works for every landlord and every property. Individualized tenancy agreements that reflect the landlord’s preferences as well as local tenancy laws are the best way for a landlord to manage a rental property. But a poorly-constructed lease will not do the job.

These are some of the more common mistakes landlords should watch for:

1. Failing to Prioritize. It is important for the lease to be drafted is such a way that the most important provisions — like the Notice to Tenant that the landlord will Report Rent Payments — are placed as close to the top of the agreement as practical and are set apart so the tenant is certain to see them. All provisions of the lease matter, but there are some that need to stand out. By lumping several provisions together in one paragraph or placing crucial language in the fine print, the landlord loses an opportunity to educate the tenant on what is expected day-to-day.

In deciding on priority, consider where income loss is most likely to occur. It’s easy to focus attention solely on the payment of rent, but that’s a once-a-month obligation. The tenant must avoid damaging the property and respect other people’s quiet enjoyment every day. Formatting using caps, bold, or headings has no impact on the legality of the tenancy agreement, but those tools are effective in helping tenants understand what is required of them.

2. Nothing Personal. The obligations of the tenancy agreement are personal to individual tenants. They live and breathe these responsibilities every day. One of the best ways to drive home that point is to personalize the tenancy agreement and demonstrate that a tenancy is a relationship in which the tenant is individually accountable. Anonymity weakens that sense of accountability. Ways to personalize the lease include:

Adding the tenant’s full legal name at the top of the lease and at the signature line;
Replacing the word “Tenant” with the tenant’s name in various places throughout the lease or including the tenant’s name in a header or footer on each page;
Including a cover letter addressed specifically to the tenant with the tenancy agreement; and
Avoiding online leasing where the landlord and tenant don’t speak. Communicating in person several times during the leasing process helps cement the relationship and amplifies a sense of accountability.

3. Oops — That’s Illegal. Most tenancy agreements include a statement that any illegal provisions — like unauthorized security deposits, late fees, application fees, or attempting to offload landlord responsibilities — should simply be disregarded and the remainder of the lease enforced. Unfortunately, that doesn’t happen in real life. In the eyes of a tenant or adjudicator, the illegal provision taints the entire lease, and the credibility of the landlord. Every word of the tenancy agreement should be binding on the tenant, and tenants should not be in a position where they question whether the lease is valid.

4. Work in Progress. There’s a science to knowing just what goes into a Tenancy Agreement. Leases with check-the-box options are particularly problematic for this reason — it’s difficult to know what to include and what to omit. That’s why it’s important to work with a legal expert before finalizing the lease form. Fortunately, once the document is complete, it will work in most situations. Commonly omitted provisions include an explanation of joint and several liability, a guest policy that covers short-term sublets and allows a landlord to run a tenant background check on new occupants, a policy for routine property inspections, and smoking restrictions.

5. It’s Not Fair! The tenancy agreement should reflect a fair bargain. The tenant must see the value in what they’ve negotiated and not feel coerced into accepting one-sided terms. An unfair lease may not be legally enforceable so there’s nothing gained. What’s more, it can impact the landlord-tenant relationship. Earning a tenant’s cooperation and trust is the best strategy for on-time rent payments and a unit returned in good condition. The alternatives are simply too costly.

This post is provided by Tenant Verification Service, Inc., helping landlords reduce the risks of renting with fraud prevention tools that include Tenant Screening, Tenant Background Checks, (U.S. and Canada), as well as Criminal Background Checks, and Eviction Reports (U.S. only).

Click Here to Receive Landlord Credit Reports.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this post is not intended to be construed as legal advice, nor should it be considered a substitute for obtaining individual legal counsel or consulting your local, state, federal or provincial tenancy laws.

Property management software for Canadian Condos.

Property Boss

Property management software for single family, multifamily, and student housing.


Screening services for property managers and landlords. Select a market below.